Hunting for a quality used saddle without breaking the bank? These five US shops have you covered, from Florida's largest consignment store to Texas-based specialists.
The Used Saddle Market: A Buyer's Paradise
The market for used saddles is booming, driven by riders who want quality without the new-saddle price tag. Consignment stores and dedicated saddle shops are curating inventories that range from barely-used English close contacts to rugged Western trail saddles. You can find everything from high-end brands like Stubben and Circle Y to budget-friendly options, all cleaned, inspected, and ready to ride. With online listings and weekly new arrivals, the convenience of shopping for used saddles has never been better. Whether you're a dressage enthusiast or a weekend trail rider, there's a used saddle out there with your name on it.
How We Evaluated These Shops
We looked at each shop's service scope, pricing clarity, and local fit. Service scope covers the range of saddle types and brands, plus extras like consignment programs or trade-in options. Pricing clarity means how transparent they are about costs, including shipping and trial policies. Local fit considers how well they serve their regional riding community, from Ocala's horse country to Texas's Western heritage. Each shop brings something unique to the table, and we've highlighted what stood out for each.
Here's a quick snapshot of the five shops we're featuring, so you can see at a glance what each one offers.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Bucks County Saddlery | English riders seeking a wide brand selection |
| Good Apple Equine Consignment | Consignment shoppers and Florida locals |
| Horse Saddle Shop | Western riders with trade-in options |
| Teskey's | Western enthusiasts seeking variety and expertise |
| R Bar B | Riders seeking a family-owned shop with a personal touch |
The Deep Dive: Your Used Saddle Shopping Guide
#1 Bucks County Saddlery
A screenshot of the Bucks County Saddlery website.
Bucks County Saddlery is a Pennsylvania-based shop with a robust online used saddle collection. They carry a wide range of brands, from Antares to Wintec, and sizes to fit most horses and riders. Their inventory includes close contact, dressage, all-purpose, and Western saddles, with clear pricing on each listing. They also offer a trial option on some saddles, which is a huge plus when buying sight-unseen. If you're looking for a specific brand or size, their filter options make it easy to narrow down the choices. Check out their used saddles page to see what's currently available.
#2 Good Apple Equine Consignment
A screenshot of the Good Apple Equine Consignment website.
Good Apple Equine Consignment, based in Ocala, Florida, is the state's largest equine consignment store, and it's a treasure trove for used saddles. They boast that more than 90% of their saddle inventory is listed online, so you can browse from anywhere. Their stock includes English, Western, and DP saddles, and they offer a free trial on saddles and harnesses, which is a game-changer. New inventory arrives weekly, so there's always something fresh to check out. They also have a consignment program where you can sell your own gear, making it a full-circle shopping experience. Whether you're a local or shopping from afar, their online presence makes it easy to find your next saddle.
#3 Horse Saddle Shop
A screenshot of the Horse Saddle Shop website.
Horse Saddle Shop, based in Texas, has over 900 saddles in stock, with a dedicated used saddle section that's constantly updated. They offer a trade-in program where you can save on a used saddle by trading in your old one, which is a smart way to upgrade. Their inventory includes trail, endurance, barrel, and ranch saddles from brands like Circle Y, Tucker, and TexTan. Each saddle is cleaned, inspected, and ready to ride, and they provide detailed descriptions and photos. They also have financing options and a saddle fit guide to help you make the right choice. If you're in the market for a Western saddle, this is a solid stop.
#4 Teskey's
A screenshot of the Teskey's website.
Teskey's, a Texas institution, offers a vast selection of used Western saddles, from barrel to roping to trail. Their online store is easy to navigate, with filters for saddle type, brand, and price. They also have a physical store where you can see the saddles in person, which is great if you're nearby. Teskey's is known for its customer service and knowledgeable staff, so you can get expert advice on fit and style. They also carry a full range of tack and apparel, making it a one-stop shop for your horse needs. If you're looking for a used saddle with a Western flair, Teskey's has you covered.
#5 R Bar B
A screenshot of the R Bar B website.
R Bar B, based in Texas, has a curated collection of 181 used saddles, with a focus on Western disciplines like ranch, roping, and trail. Their website allows you to filter by availability and price, making it easy to find something in your budget. They also offer a range of used tack, from bits to saddle pads, so you can outfit your horse completely. R Bar B is family-owned and has a strong community feel, which is reflected in their customer service. If you're looking for a quality used saddle from a trusted name, R Bar B is worth a look. Their inventory changes regularly, so check back often.
How to Choose the Right Used Saddle Shop
When picking a used saddle shop, start by considering your discipline and saddle type—English or Western—and then look for shops that specialize in that area. Check their online inventory to see if they have the brands and sizes you're interested in, and pay attention to their return or trial policies. If you're buying online, make sure they provide detailed photos and measurements, and don't hesitate to call or email with questions. Also, consider the shop's location and whether you can visit in person, as that can be a big advantage for fitting. Finally, read reviews or ask for recommendations from fellow riders to gauge their reputation.
Streamline Your Saddle Search
To make your search easier, set up alerts on these shops' websites for new arrivals that match your criteria. Many of them update their inventory weekly, so you can be the first to see a great deal. You can also follow them on social media for flash sales or special promotions. If you're consigning, use their online appointment systems to get your gear listed quickly. And don't forget to bookmark your favorite shops so you can check back regularly without having to search again.
Your Next Saddle Awaits
Finding the perfect used saddle doesn't have to be a chore. With these five shops, you have a range of options, from Florida's consignment giant to Texas's Western specialists. Each offers something unique, whether it's a free trial, trade-in program, or a family-owned touch. So, take your time, browse their inventories, and you'll be riding in style without emptying your wallet. Happy saddle hunting!