INTERVIEW | 5 min read

The Price of Candour: Sandeep Aujla on Who Pays Most to Speak Up at Work

Last edited: Nov 19, 2026
Listen
--:--
The Price of Candour: Sandeep Aujla on Who Pays Most to Speak Up at Work hero image

When the Standard Advice Doesn't Fit

Most guidance on psychological safety asks two things: the leader invites input, and the team member finds the courage to give it. Sandeep Aujla, executive and team coach at Multilevel Leadership Consulting Inc., argues that this advice assumes something that is often untrue — that speaking up costs roughly the same for everyone on the team.

"It leaves too much to chance when one or two people still pay more than the rest to say what they see, and a good team score can hide them," she said.

Aujla measures psychological safety at the start and end of her team coaching and cohort programs. When she shares results, she does not stop at the average. She shows the lowest and highest scores, the median, and the spread. On teams with a comfortable average, that view often reveals someone well below it. The question she puts to the team is direct: if even one person here does not feel safe, is that acceptable to us?

Her answer is to design for safety on purpose. Teams set aside time to build their own Equitable Psychological Safety Standard — specific commitments from the leader, from the team as a whole, and from each member about what they will do when someone disagrees, raises a concern, or admits a mistake. Teams that adopt the standard and keep honouring it, she says, make high psychological safety more likely for everyone, not only for those who already felt safe.

A standard does not prevent every breakdown. When one happens, Aujla moves to one-to-one coaching, where the person can work out which barriers are perceived and which are real before deciding on a next step. The full framework is set out in her flagship essay on equitable psychological safety.

The Cost Shows Up After the Meeting

Even well-run meetings with sincere invitations can leave people silent. Aujla's explanation is that an invitation gives everyone permission to speak, but it does not make speaking cost the same for everyone. People decide based on the cost.

Part of the answer, she argues, sits with team members. "I believe courage to speak needs to go hand in hand with accountability for how we speak," she said, noting that Amy Edmondson, who defined psychological safety, has made the same point: safety is not comfort, and it does not lower the bar.

That responsibility is fair only when the consequences are. What Aujla sees most often is that the cost appears after the meeting, not in it. A concern from a director is passed over and taken up when a vice-president says the same thing. The real conversation moves to the hallway. Sometimes the leader responds well in the room and adverse consequences arrive months later — in an assignment, a performance conversation, or a relationship that loses its warmth.

"People who have been punished for speaking up, or have watched it happen to a colleague, draw a reasonable conclusion," she said.

In those cases another invitation will not help. The leader needs to take stock of what beliefs or judgments formed during moments of dissent and how they turned into consequences afterwards. Then the work is relationship repair, with the leader taking accountability too. Aujla suggests starting with one question: what happened the last time someone raised something unwelcome here, and who was watching?

Speak Up Must Not Mean Speak Out Loud

For managers trying to open up a quiet team, Aujla names a common early mistake: treating "speak up" as "speak out loud." For more reserved people, and in more reserved team cultures, those are very different requests. Calling on the quiet person in the room can feel inclusive, but it asks them to take the risk in public.

She points to several channels that do not depend on speaking in the room: everyone writes their thinking on sticky notes and every note goes up before discussion begins; the team uses anonymous polling through tools such as Slido or Mentimeter on questions where a named answer would carry a cost; and the manager holds conversations before the meeting so themes can be raised without attaching them to a person.

These channels only work if what arrives through them carries the same weight as what is said aloud. "The worst choice is to refuse to flex what speaking up looks like and insist it happen out loud, regardless of individual differences, cultural norms, or the sensitivity of the topic," she said. That can read as a high standard, but in practice it rewards the people who already found speaking easy.

Two other early mistakes are worth watching. One is reading silence as agreement or as a performance problem; more often, a quiet team has learned what speaking up costs, sometimes under a previous leader. The other is thanking people only when they turn out to be right — the team then learns to speak only when certain, when a manager needs concerns before certainty.

Underneath it all, Aujla says, the team learns more from the manager's response than from the invitation. The first ten seconds after someone contributes set the price for everyone watching. A new manager does not need to end the team's silence in a month. A useful early goal is a pattern of responses that makes the next concern a little cheaper to raise for everyone on the team.