Planning a wedding, corporate lunch, or family celebration in Pittsburgh? You need a caterer who can handle the details, deliver fresh food, and keep your guests happy. After digging into the local scene, I've rounded up five caterers that stand
Pittsburgh's Catering Scene: Fresh, Local, and Built for Any Event
Pittsburgh's catering industry is as diverse as its neighborhoods. From family-owned operations that have been around for decades to modern full-service companies, the city offers options for every budget and style. Many caterers here emphasize fresh, locally sourced ingredients and flexible service models. You can find everything from elegant plated dinners to casual BBQ buffets. The best caterers also prioritize clear communication and reliable delivery, which is crucial when you're feeding a crowd. Whether you're in the North Hills, South Hills, or Allegheny Valley, there's a caterer ready to make your event seamless.
How I Ranked These Pittsburgh Caterers
I evaluated each caterer based on five key factors: menu variety and customization, service options (full-service, drop-off, pickup), years of experience and reputation, client feedback and awards, and geographic coverage. I also considered how well each caterer communicates and handles logistics like delivery, setup, and cleanup. The goal was to find caterers that not only serve great food but also make the planning process easy for you.
Here's a quick look at the top five Pittsburgh caterers, ranked from best overall to a solid choice for specific needs.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Common Plea Catering | Upscale weddings and corporate galas |
| Remo's Catering | BBQ lovers and casual celebrations |
| All In Good Taste Productions | Full-service events with design and planning |
| Pittsburgh's Favorite Catering Company - Cooked Goose Catering | Flexible catering for any occasion |
| The Chef and I Catering | Couples planning a wedding with a custom menu |
Deep Dive: The Top 5 Pittsburgh Caterers
#1 Common Plea Catering
A screenshot of the Common Plea Catering website.
Common Plea Catering has been a Pittsburgh staple for over fifty years, specializing in chef-driven cuisine for weddings, corporate galas, and private celebrations. They offer elegant plated dinners, interactive food stations, and family-style meals, all customized to your vision. Their team handles everything from menu design to seamless execution, making them a top choice for high-end events. They also partner with many premier venues across Western Pennsylvania, which simplifies your planning. If you want an unforgettable dining experience with professional service from start to finish, Common Plea delivers.
#2 Remo's Catering
A screenshot of the Remo's Catering website.
Remo's Catering brings five generations of experience to the Pittsburgh catering scene, with a focus on weddings, corporate events, and BBQ. They are known for their mobile BBQ grills and pit cooks, which add a lively, interactive element to any gathering. Remo's also offers full bar service and custom menus, making them a versatile choice for everything from graduations to picnics. Their drop-off service includes setup, so you don't have to worry about the details. With a 4.8-star rating from over 360 reviews, they have a loyal following.
#3 All In Good Taste Productions
A screenshot of the All In Good Taste Productions website.
All In Good Taste Productions has been a trusted name in Pittsburgh catering and event planning for over 35 years. They specialize in creating custom experiences for weddings, corporate events, and private parties, with a focus on signature cuisine and impeccable décor. Their team handles every detail, from intimate dinner parties to grand receptions, ensuring your vision comes to life. Located in the Mexican War Streets, they serve the entire Pittsburgh area with professionalism and creativity. If you want a caterer that also offers event design and planning, this is a strong pick.
#4 Pittsburgh's Favorite Catering Company - Cooked Goose Catering
A screenshot of the Cooked Goose Catering website.
Cooked Goose Catering is a family-owned business that has been serving Pittsburgh for over 45 years, offering fresh, family-prepared food for weddings, corporate lunches, and celebrations. Their menu is extensive, covering everything from appetizers and charcuterie trays to boxed lunches, BBQ, and homemade takeout. They provide flexible service options including pickup, drop-off, and full-service with delivery, setup, and cleanup. Their corporate clients include PNC, UPMC, and the Pittsburgh Penguins, which speaks to their reliability. Voted #1 Best Caterer in Pittsburgh, they emphasize easy ordering and clear communication, making them a solid choice for any event.
#5 The Chef and I Catering
A screenshot of the The Chef and I Catering website.
The Chef and I Catering is a full-service catering company based in Brackenridge, Pennsylvania, serving the Pittsburgh region and Allegheny Valley. They specialize in weddings, corporate events, and private parties, offering plated dinners, elegant buffets, and station-style receptions. They are a preferred caterer at select venues, which can simplify your venue selection process. With awards from The Knot and Wedding Wire, they have a strong reputation for quality and service. If you want a caterer that tailors every menu to your story, The Chef and I is worth considering.
How to Choose the Right Pittsburgh Caterer for Your Event
Start by defining the type of event you're hosting. A formal wedding might call for a full-service caterer like Common Plea, while a backyard BBQ could be perfect for Remo's. Consider your budget and guest count, and ask about service options like drop-off, setup, and cleanup. Look for caterers with experience in your specific event type, and read reviews to gauge reliability. Finally, schedule a tasting to ensure the food matches your expectations. The right caterer will make the process feel effortless.
Automate Your Catering Search with These Workflows
You can streamline your catering research by setting up a simple workflow. Use a tool like Zapier to monitor review sites for new feedback on these caterers, then get alerts via email or Slack. Create a spreadsheet to compare menu options, pricing, and availability, and update it automatically as you gather quotes. You can also set reminders to follow up with caterers after initial inquiries. This keeps your planning organized and saves time.
Final Synthesis: Your Next Step in Pittsburgh Catering
Pittsburgh's catering scene is rich with options, from decades-old family businesses to modern full-service companies. Whether you need a simple drop-off lunch or an elaborate wedding reception, these five caterers have proven their ability to deliver. Start by reaching out to the ones that match your event style, and don't hesitate to ask for references or sample menus. With the right caterer, your event will be memorable for all the right reasons.