Planning an event in Pittsburgh? Whether it's an intimate dinner party, a corporate luncheon, or a grand wedding, the right caterer can make all the difference. We've tasted, tested, and researched the top players in the Steel City to bring
The Pittsburgh Catering Scene: Fresh, Local, and Personal
Pittsburgh's catering industry is as diverse as its neighborhoods. You'll find everything from classic, elegant full-service operations to nimble, boutique kitchens that specialize in small events. A strong emphasis on local sourcing is a common thread, with many caterers partnering with regional farms and purveyors. The trend is moving toward personalized, chef-driven menus that reflect the host's vision, whether that's a Mediterranean-inspired spread or a classic American buffet. This guide highlights the best of the best, each with a unique strength.
How We Ranked the Best Caterers
Our rankings are based on a combination of factors: menu quality and customization, service reliability, years of experience, client reviews, and unique differentiators like venue partnerships or special event types. We also considered the caterer's ability to handle both large-scale events and intimate gatherings, as well as their commitment to using fresh, local ingredients.
Here's a quick look at our top five caterers in Pittsburgh, each excelling in a specific area.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Common Plea Catering | Large-scale elegant events and weddings |
| Bistro To Go & Company | Creative, seasonal catering with a cafe vibe |
| Cooked Goose Catering | Everyday events and stress-free catering |
| Above & Beyond Catering and Kitchen | Intimate events with Mediterranean flair |
| Remo's Catering | BBQ and festive, large gatherings |
The Top 5 Caterers in Pittsburgh: In-Depth Reviews
#1 Common Plea Catering
A screenshot of the Common Plea Catering website.
Common Plea Catering has been a Pittsburgh institution for over fifty years, earning a reputation for 'uncommonly good' service and cuisine. They specialize in elegant plated dinners, interactive food stations, and lavish buffets for weddings, corporate galas, and fundraisers. Every menu is fully customized to your event, and they partner with many of the city's premier venues. Their team of experienced event planners ensures seamless execution from start to finish. If you're planning a large, high-stakes event, Common Plea is the gold standard.
#2 Bistro To Go & Company
A screenshot of the Bistro To Go & Company website.
Bistro To Go & Company brings a touch of artistry to every event, from formal weddings to whimsical receptions. They offer a range of service styles, including delivery, pickup, and fully staffed events, making them incredibly versatile. Their seasonal menus are handcrafted and stress-free, and they are a preferred vendor at venues like Phipps Conservatory. With a charming cafe in the Historic Northside, they also offer a la carte options for a quick bite. Bistro is perfect for those who want a blend of creativity and reliability.
#3 Cooked Goose Catering
A screenshot of the Cooked Goose Catering website.
Cooked Goose Catering is a family-prepared operation that delivers fresh, dependable service across Pittsburgh. They cover every type of event, from weddings and corporate lunches to bereavements and graduation parties. Their menu is extensive, with options like BBQ, boxed lunches, and build-your-own brunch, making it easy to find something for everyone. They offer delivery, setup, and full-service options, taking the stress off the host. Cooked Goose is the go-to for no-fuss, reliable catering that still feels special.
#4 Above & Beyond Catering and Kitchen
A screenshot of the Above & Beyond Catering and Kitchen website.
Above & Beyond Catering and Kitchen is a Pittsburgh-based gem that has been operating since 2003, focusing on smaller events to ensure freshness and personal service. They offer customizable menus ranging from small bites to plated dinners, and also host cooking classes and pop-up dinners. Their Middle Eastern and Mediterranean background shines through in their use of seasonal, local ingredients sourced from farms like Goodness Grows Farm and Churchview Farm. They are a preferred caterer for the University of Pittsburgh and the Energy Innovation Center. For an intimate, personalized experience with a unique flavor profile, this is your spot.
#5 Remo's Catering
A screenshot of the Remo's Catering website.
Remo's Catering has been voted the Best Caterer in Pittsburgh, backed by five generations of experience. They are wedding specialists but also excel at corporate events, graduations, and picnics, offering custom menus and on-site BBQ grills. Their mobile BBQ and pig roasts are a crowd-pleaser, and they provide full bar service. With a 4.8-star rating from over 360 reviews, they are trusted by thousands of repeat customers. Remo's is the perfect choice for a fun, flavorful, and festive event.
How to Choose the Right Caterer for You
Start by defining the size and style of your event. For a large, formal wedding, Common Plea Catering is unmatched. If you want creative, seasonal menus with a cafe touch, go with Bistro To Go & Company. For everyday reliability and a wide menu, Cooked Goose Catering is your best bet. If you're planning an intimate gathering with a focus on fresh, local ingredients and Mediterranean flavors, choose Above & Beyond Catering and Kitchen. And for a festive, BBQ-heavy celebration, Remo's Catering will bring the party.
Streamline Your Event Planning
Once you've chosen your caterer, use online ordering and event management tools to simplify the process. Many caterers, like Bistro To Go & Company and Cooked Goose, offer easy online ordering for drop-off events. For staffed events, set up a shared digital timeline with your caterer to coordinate delivery, setup, and service. Automate guest count updates and menu selections through a simple spreadsheet or event app to keep everything on track.
Your Perfect Pittsburgh Event Starts Here
Pittsburgh's catering scene is rich with options, each offering a unique blend of quality, service, and personality. Whether you need the elegance of Common Plea, the creativity of Bistro To Go, the reliability of Cooked Goose, the intimacy of Above & Beyond, or the festive spirit of Remo's, you can't go wrong. The key is matching the caterer's strengths to your event's needs. Book a tasting, ask questions, and trust your instincts. Your perfect event is just a menu away.