Planning a wedding, corporate gala, or milestone celebration in Pittsburgh? The right caterer can make or break your event. We've tasted, tested, and ranked the top five catering companies in the Steel City to help you find the perfect match
The Pittsburgh Catering Scene in 2026
Pittsburgh's catering industry has evolved into a dynamic mix of old-school institutions and creative newcomers. From elegant plated dinners at downtown venues to relaxed backyard barbecues, local caterers now offer everything from full-service event planning to simple drop-off meals. The best companies combine chef-driven cuisine with seamless execution, often partnering with top venues across the region. Whether you need a wedding feast for 200 or a corporate lunch for 50, Pittsburgh's caterers are ready to impress.
How We Ranked the Best
We evaluated each caterer on five key factors: menu variety and customization, quality of ingredients and presentation, service professionalism, years of experience and reputation, and overall value for the price. We also considered client reviews, awards, and the ability to handle events of all sizes.
Here's a quick look at our top five Pittsburgh caterers, from the most versatile to the most specialized.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Common Plea Catering | Full-service elegance and large-scale events |
| All In Good Taste Productions | Creative event design and personalized planning |
| Remo's Catering | BBQ and on-site grilling events |
| Catering & Deli | Pittsburgh, PA | Erin’s Fine Foods | Freshly baked goods and deli-style catering |
| The Chef and I Catering | Luxury weddings and personalized menus |
The Top 5 Pittsburgh Caterers, Reviewed
#1 Common Plea Catering
A screenshot of the Common Plea Catering website.
Common Plea Catering has been a Pittsburgh staple for over fifty years, earning a reputation for chef-driven cuisine and flawless execution. They specialize in elegant plated dinners, over-the-top buffets, interactive food stations, and passed hors d'oeuvres for weddings, corporate galas, and private celebrations. Every menu is fully customized to your event and vision, and they partner with many of the city's premier venues. Their team handles everything from intimate dinners to black-tie galas with hundreds of guests. Client feedback consistently highlights their attention to detail and refined presentation. If you want an uncommonly good experience, Common Plea delivers.
#2 All In Good Taste Productions
A screenshot of the All In Good Taste Productions website.
For over 35 years, All In Good Taste Productions has been a trusted name in Pittsburgh catering and event planning. Based in the Mexican War Streets, they create unforgettable experiences for weddings, corporate events, and private parties. Their team handles every detail with professionalism and creativity, from intimate dinner parties to grand wedding receptions. They offer custom menus, stunning event design, and impeccable service across the city. Whether you're planning a corporate luncheon downtown or an elegant wedding in Shadyside, they bring your vision to life. Their longevity and client loyalty speak volumes.
#3 Remo's Catering
A screenshot of the Remo's Catering website.
Remo's Catering has been voted Best Caterer in Pittsburgh, backed by five generations of experience and thousands of satisfied customers. They specialize in weddings, corporate events, and social gatherings, with a unique flair for on-site BBQ and pig roasts. Their mobile grills and pit cooks bring your event to life, whether at their event center or your chosen venue. They also offer full bar service and flexible drop-off catering options. Remo's is known for fresh, high-quality food and a dedicated staff of chefs, servers, and coordinators. If you want a caterer that combines tradition with a fun, festive vibe, Remo's is a top pick.
#4 Catering & Deli | Pittsburgh, PA | Erin’s Fine Foods
A screenshot of the Catering & Deli | Pittsburgh, PA | Erin’s Fine Foods website.
Erin's Fine Foods has been a Pittsburgh staple since 2004, catering hundreds of weddings and over a thousand other events. They offer full-service catering for weddings, private events, and corporate functions, using only the finest products and a professional wait staff. What sets them apart is their in-house bakery and pastry chef, who makes all food and bread fresh daily. They also run an upscale deli serving breakfast, lunch, coffee, and pastries, with indoor seating, a bar, and outdoor summer seating. With two convenient locations in Pittsburgh, they bring a homey yet refined touch to every event. For a caterer that doubles as a beloved local deli, Erin's is a hidden gem.
#5 The Chef and I Catering
A screenshot of the The Chef and I Catering website.
The Chef and I Catering is a full-service catering company based in Brackenridge, serving the Pittsburgh region and Allegheny Valley. They specialize in luxury catering for couples who refuse to compromise on food, presentation, or experience. Their menus range from plated dinners and elegant buffets to casual wedding receptions with all-inclusive packages. They are a preferred caterer at select venues and have earned multiple awards from The Knot and Wedding Wire. Their team focuses on tailoring every detail to your story, making each event feel personal and polished. If you want a caterer that treats your celebration like a work of art, The Chef and I delivers.
How to Choose the Right Caterer for Your Event
Start by defining your event type and guest count. For a formal wedding or corporate gala, full-service caterers like Common Plea or All In Good Taste are ideal. If you want a relaxed BBQ vibe, Remo's is your best bet. For events that benefit from freshly baked bread and pastries, Erin's Fine Foods adds a unique touch. Always schedule a tasting to ensure the food matches your expectations, and ask about customization options. Finally, check if the caterer is a preferred vendor at your venue to simplify logistics.
Streamline Your Event Planning with Automation
Use a tool like Zapier to connect your event planning spreadsheet to your email. When you add a new caterer to your list, automatically send a tasting request email. You can also set reminders for follow-ups and budget tracking. This keeps your planning organized and ensures you never miss a step.
Your Perfect Pittsburgh Caterer Awaits
Pittsburgh's catering scene offers something for every taste and budget. Whether you choose the time-tested elegance of Common Plea, the creative flair of All In Good Taste, the festive BBQ of Remo's, the fresh-baked charm of Erin's Fine Foods, or the luxury of The Chef and I, you're in good hands. Book a tasting, ask questions, and trust your instincts. Your next great event starts with the right caterer.