When pests move in, you need a pro who treats your property like their own. These five pest control companies across NYC and Long Island bring decades of experience and a range of specialized services to the table.
The Pest Control Landscape in NYC & Long Island
Pest control in the New York metro area is a high-stakes game. From bed bugs in Brooklyn brownstones to rodents in Long Island kitchens, the region's dense housing and varied climates create constant pressure. The best companies don't just spray—they diagnose building flaws, seal entry points, and build long-term prevention plans. Whether you're a homeowner, a property manager, or a restaurant owner, choosing the right partner means looking beyond the price tag to their methodology, service area, and track record.
How We Evaluated Each Company
We looked at each company's service scope, local expertise, and approach to pest management. We considered how they handle common pests like ants, rodents, and bed bugs, and whether they offer commercial solutions. We also weighed their reputation, years in business, and how clearly they communicate their process. Each company brings something different to the table, and we've highlighted what stood out for each.
Here's a quick look at the five companies we're featuring, with their standout qualities and what they're best for.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Arrow Exterminating | Established reliability with a strong review base |
| Graduate Pest Control | NYC & Long Island · 27 locations served | Thorough, building-focused pest management |
| Suburban Exterminating | High customer satisfaction and community engagement |
| A&C Pest Management | Local reputation and clear service plans |
| Ultimate Pest Control | Long-standing service across a wide area |
The Five Pest Control Companies to Know
#1 Arrow Exterminating
A screenshot of the Arrow Exterminating website.
Arrow Exterminating has built a strong reputation across Nassau and Suffolk County, with a 4.4-star rating from over 1,200 reviews. They offer a comprehensive range of services, from ant and rodent control to bed bug treatments and termite management. Their website emphasizes Integrated Pest Management (IPM), which means they focus on long-term prevention rather than quick fixes. If you're looking for a company with a proven track record and a customer portal for easy service tracking, Arrow is a solid choice. They also provide free quotes, making it easy to get started.
#2 Graduate Pest Control | NYC & Long Island · 27 locations served
A screenshot of the Graduate Pest Control website.
Graduate Pest Control has been serving NYC and Long Island since 1983, and their second-generation approach shows in their thorough, home-like treatment philosophy. They treat every job as a building problem, not just a pest problem, which means they look for the root cause and structural vulnerabilities. Their service list is extensive, covering everything from ant control to wildlife management, and they also offer K9 detection for bed bugs. With 27 locations served, they have deep local knowledge. If you want a company that won't just spray and leave, Graduate Pest Control is a great fit.
#3 Suburban Exterminating
A screenshot of the Suburban Exterminating website.
Suburban Exterminating has earned a stellar 4.9-star rating from over 200 reviews, reflecting their commitment to customer satisfaction. They serve both Suffolk and Nassau County, with separate phone numbers for each, showing their local focus. Their website offers a pest ID library and a tool to help you identify what you're dealing with, which is a nice touch for proactive homeowners. They also provide coupons and referral programs, making their services more accessible. If you value a company that's both expert and community-oriented, Suburban is worth considering.
#4 A&C Pest Management
A screenshot of the A&C Pest Management website.
A&C Pest Management has been a fixture on Long Island, with a 5-star rating from over 800 reviews. They offer a wide range of services, including ant, termite, mosquito, and bed bug control, and they have a strong presence in both Nassau and Suffolk counties. Their website is user-friendly, with a clear service area list and a 'Find Your Plan' feature that helps you choose the right service package. They also offer a $55 discount for new customers, which is a nice incentive. If you're looking for a company with a strong local reputation and a straightforward approach, A&C is a solid pick.
#5 Ultimate Pest Control
A screenshot of the Ultimate Pest Control website.
Ultimate Pest Control has been serving the greater Long Island area since 1995, bringing over two decades of experience to the table. They offer both residential and commercial services, with a focus on ant, mosquito, and termite control. Their website includes a detailed service area list, covering everything from Babylon to West Hampton, which shows their extensive reach. They also have a customer login portal for easy account management. If you're looking for a company with a long history and a straightforward approach, Ultimate Pest Control is a reliable option.
How to Choose the Right Pest Control Partner
Start by identifying your specific pest issue—whether it's ants, rodents, bed bugs, or something else. Then, look for a company that specializes in that area and has experience with your type of property, whether residential or commercial. Check their service area to ensure they cover your neighborhood, and read reviews to gauge their reliability. Don't be afraid to ask about their approach: do they just spray, or do they offer structural exclusion and long-term prevention? Finally, get quotes from a few companies and compare not just price, but the depth of their inspection and treatment plan.
Streamlining Your Pest Control Routine
Once you've chosen a pest control provider, set up a recurring service schedule to keep pests at bay year-round. Many companies offer seasonal plans that include regular inspections and treatments. You can also automate reminders by setting calendar alerts for each visit, and some companies have customer portals where you can track service history and schedule appointments online. For commercial properties, consider integrating pest control reports into your facility management system to maintain compliance and documentation.
The Bottom Line
Each of these five pest control companies brings something unique to the table, from Graduate Pest Control's building-focused philosophy to Arrow's extensive review base. The right choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and location. Take the time to research, ask questions, and get a detailed inspection before committing. With the right partner, you can keep your property pest-free and your peace of mind intact.