Craving that authentic taste of the Maine coast without leaving Michigan? These five spots bring the ocean to you, each with its own unique twist on New England classics.
The New England Seafood Scene in Michigan
Michigan might be known for its Great Lakes, but that hasn't stopped a passionate wave of seafood lovers from bringing the flavors of the Atlantic to the Midwest. From the shores of Lake Michigan to the bays of Traverse City, restaurants are serving up lobster rolls, clam chowder, and fish n' chips with a dedication that rivals any coastal shack. What's striking is how each place interprets 'New England style'—some go for the rustic, no-frills approach, while others elevate it with fine dining touches. For you, this means a delightful range of options, whether you're after a quick lunch or a sunset dinner. The key is finding the spot that matches your craving and your vibe.
How We Evaluated Each Spot
To bring you this roundup, we looked at each restaurant through the lens of what matters most to you: the authenticity of the New England flavors, the clarity of their menu and pricing, the overall experience they offer, and how well they fit into the local dining scene. We considered the variety of seafood options, from classic lobster rolls to creative daily specials, and how each place communicates its offerings online. We also noted the atmosphere—whether it's a casual window service or a waterfront fine dining experience—and how that shapes your visit. Each business stood out in its own way, and we're excited to share what makes them worth your time.
Here's a quick look at the five spots we're featuring, so you can see at a glance what each one brings to the table.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Hazel's | Live lobster and summer lobster pound experiences |
| Goody's Lobster Shack - New England Seafood in Frankfort, MI | Authentic lobster rolls and fish n' chips in a casual setting |
| Apache Trout Grill | Waterfront dining with a view of Grand Traverse Bay |
| Harringtons By The Bay | Creative seafood dishes with a panoramic bay view |
| Boathouse Restaurant | Romantic dinners and sunset views on Bowers Harbor |
The Deep Dive: Your Top 5 New England Seafood Destinations
#1 Hazel's
A screenshot of the Hazel's website.
Hazel's in Birmingham is your summer ticket to Maine, with live lobsters flown in fresh and a Lobster Pound that's a seasonal highlight. You'll find whole lobsters, lobster rolls, and fresh oysters on the half shell, all served with that easy New England vibe. The menu also features fried shrimp, clams, and a popular whitefish paté, plus a hearty steam pot loaded with sausage, corn, and your choice of shrimp or snow crab. It's a place where you can dig in with your hands and feel the salt air, even if you're miles from the coast. The online ordering makes it easy to bring that coastal taste home, too. For a true taste of Maine in Michigan, Hazel's is a must-visit.
#2 Goody's Lobster Shack - New England Seafood in Frankfort, MI
A screenshot of the Goody's Lobster Shack website.
Goody's Lobster Shack brings the charm of a Maine lobster shack to Frankfort, with a focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients and authentic New England recipes. You can grab a classic battered fish n' chips, a sweet lobster roll, or a cup of their New England clam chowder, all served fresh daily. They operate two locations: a lunch window on Main Street and a dinner spot at Furnace St. Distillery, giving you flexibility in how you enjoy your meal. The menu also includes crab cakes, lobster bisque, and a seared ahi tuna that adds a modern twist. It's a casual, welcoming spot that feels like a true coastal find. If you're in the area, this is the place for a quick, delicious seafood fix.
#3 Apache Trout Grill
A screenshot of the Apache Trout Grill website.
Apache Trout Grill sits right on the shores of Grand Traverse Bay, offering stunning waterfront views that pair perfectly with their fresh seafood and hand-cut steaks. Founded in 1994, this Traverse City staple has a rich history and a menu that highlights local ingredients, from seasonal specialties to their famous West Bay Bloody Mary. You can enjoy Sunday brunch, order online for pickup or delivery, or join their rewards program for extra perks. The atmosphere is relaxed yet refined, making it a great spot for a leisurely meal with a view. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Apache Trout Grill delivers a memorable dining experience.
#4 Harringtons By The Bay
A screenshot of the Harringtons By The Bay website.
Harringtons By The Bay offers a more elevated take on seafood, with fresh, creative cooking and a commitment to first-class customer service. Located on the shores of West Grand Traverse Bay, you'll enjoy panoramic views of the water and downtown Traverse City from their dining room or seasonal outdoor seating. Their all-day menu features a variety of dishes, and the Red 8 Lounge provides a daily happy hour with perfect wine pairings. It's a favorite among year-round residents and visitors alike, thanks to its warm atmosphere and attention to detail. If you're looking for a special occasion spot or just a great meal with a view, Harringtons delivers.
#5 Boathouse Restaurant
A screenshot of the Boathouse Restaurant website.
The Boathouse Restaurant, nestled on the shores of Bowers Harbor, offers a dining experience that's as much about the ambiance as the food. With wide-open windows and a summer deck, you'll have a delightful view of the docks and bay, and the cozy cottage decor makes you feel right at home. Their culinary team focuses on the entire plate, combining flavor, texture, and presentation for a memorable meal. You can enjoy Sunday brunch, cocktails by the fireplace, or dinner during their exclusive sunset views. It's a place where dining out becomes an occasion of joy and fulfillment, as owner Doug Kosch puts it. For a truly special evening, the Boathouse is a top pick.
How to Choose Your Perfect Seafood Spot
When you're deciding where to go, think about what kind of experience you're craving. If you want a casual, quick bite with authentic lobster rolls and fish n' chips, Goody's Lobster Shack is your go-to. For a summer lobster pound with live lobsters and a lively atmosphere, Hazel's is the place. If you're after a waterfront view with a broader menu, Apache Trout Grill or Harringtons By The Bay are excellent choices. And for a special occasion with a focus on ambiance and creative dishes, the Boathouse Restaurant is ideal. Consider the vibe, the menu, and the setting—each of these spots offers something unique, so you really can't go wrong.
Streamlining Your Seafood Search
To make your decision easier, you can use online ordering and reservation systems to your advantage. Hazel's and Apache Trout Grill both offer online ordering for pickup or delivery, so you can enjoy their seafood from the comfort of your home. For dine-in, Harringtons and the Boathouse encourage reservations, especially during peak times, to ensure you get a table with the best view. Goody's Lobster Shack has a straightforward schedule with lunch and dinner windows, so you can plan your visit around their hours. By using these tools, you can save time and make sure your seafood craving is satisfied without any hassle.
The Final Word on Michigan's New England Seafood
Michigan's New England seafood scene is thriving, and these five spots prove that you don't need to be on the coast to enjoy the freshest tastes of the Atlantic. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lobster roll at Goody's, a live lobster feast at Hazel's, or a waterfront dinner at Apache Trout Grill, there's something here for every palate and occasion. Each restaurant brings its own unique charm and dedication to quality, so you can trust that your meal will be a memorable one. So go ahead, explore these local gems, and let your taste buds take a trip to New England without leaving the state.