If you're on the hunt for a bagel that's kettle-boiled, oven-baked, and worth waking up for, these five Long Island spots have you covered. From family-owned counters to full-scale caterers, here's where to get your fix.
The Long Island Bagel Scene
Long Island has a bagel culture that's practically a religion. The classic New York bagel—crispy outside, chewy inside—is the gold standard, and these shops take it seriously. Whether you're grabbing a morning bite, ordering lunch for the office, or planning a big event, the right bagel shop can make all the difference. In 2026, the best spots are blending tradition with convenience, offering online ordering, catering menus, and multiple locations to serve you better.
How We Evaluated These Bagel Shops
We looked at each shop's service scope, pricing clarity, and local fit. Service scope covers everything from daily breakfast to full catering. Pricing clarity means how easy it is to find menu prices and order online. Local fit considers how well each shop serves its immediate community. Each of these five shops stood out in its own way—some for their extensive catering options, others for their classic approach and community roots.
Here's a quick snapshot of the five bagel shops we're highlighting, so you can see at a glance what each one brings to the table.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Long Island Bagel Café | Convenient multi-location ordering |
| oody's Bagels & Spreads | Greenvale & Jericho, NY | Family-owned local flavor |
| Brendel's Bagels | Full-service catering and events |
| The Bagel Place Caterers | Custom platters and BBQ catering |
| Bagel Boss East Northport | Early morning grab-and-go |
The Deep Dive: 5 Bagel Shops to Know
#1 Long Island Bagel Café
A screenshot of the Long Island Bagel Café website.
Long Island Bagel Café has been a staple for years, with nine locations across Long Island, plus spots in Scarsdale and Boca Raton. They use time-tested recipes for hand-rolled, old-fashioned New York bagels, and their catering menu is a big draw for events. You can order online easily, and their website is clear about menus and locations. If you want a reliable bagel with a side of convenience, this is a solid pick. Check out their catering page for party platters and more.
#2 oody's Bagels & Spreads | Greenvale & Jericho, NY
A screenshot of the Goody's Bagels & Spreads website.
Goody's Bagels & Spreads is a family-owned gem with two Long Island locations in Greenvale and Jericho. They're all about kettle-boiled, oven-baked bagels made fresh every morning, and they open at 6 AM daily for early birds. Their website makes it easy to order online, check menus, or get details on catering for your next event. You can also text your order at the Jericho location, which is a nice touch. If you're looking for a local spot that feels personal and serves up classic bagels, this is it.
#3 Brendel's Bagels
Brendel's Bagels positions itself as Long Island's premier full catering service and bagel company. They offer extensive breakfast, lunch, dinner, and even barbecue catering, with three locations in Centereach and Hauppauge. Their website is packed with menus, and you can order online or call their 1-866-CATERING line. They emphasize using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, and their reviews are strong. If you're planning a big event, Brendel's has the scale to handle it.
#4 The Bagel Place Caterers
A screenshot of The Bagel Place Caterers website.
The Bagel Place Caterers focuses on service and community, with a store that prides itself on going above and beyond. They offer a catering menu, corporate event catering, and even backyard BBQ services, so they're more than just bagels. Their website is simple but functional, with a downloadable catering menu and contact info. If you're looking for a place that treats you like a neighbor, this is a good bet. They also have platter customization, which is handy for parties.
#5 Bagel Boss East Northport
A screenshot of the Bagel Boss East Northport website.
Bagel Boss East Northport is part of a well-known local chain, with locations in East Northport and Massapequa. They open as early as 5 AM, so you can get your bagel fix before the day starts. Their website covers menus, catering, and holiday packages, making it easy to plan ahead. They also have a shiva catering menu, which shows they understand community needs. If you need a dependable bagel shop with a broad menu, Bagel Boss has you covered.
How to Pick Your Bagel Spot
Start by thinking about what you need. If it's a quick breakfast, look for a shop with early hours and online ordering. For lunch or office catering, check if they have a dedicated catering menu and delivery options. Consider the location—having a shop near you or with multiple branches can be a game-changer. And don't forget to check if they offer customization, like platters or special orders. The right choice depends on your priorities, so weigh what matters most to you.
Streamline Your Bagel Ordering
You can save time by using online ordering systems that many of these shops offer. For example, Goody's lets you text your order at their Jericho location, while Long Island Bagel Café has a straightforward online order page. If you're planning a recurring event, set up a standing order with a caterer like Brendel's or The Bagel Place. Automating your bagel runs means less waiting and more eating.
The Bottom Line on Long Island Bagels
Long Island is spoiled for choice when it comes to bagels, and these five shops each bring something unique. Whether you're after a family-owned feel, a catering powerhouse, or just a reliable morning bagel, there's a spot for you. Try a few, see which one becomes your go-to, and enjoy the chewy, crispy goodness that only a proper New York bagel can deliver.