Planning an event in Columbus? Whether it's a corporate luncheon, a wedding reception, or an intimate gathering, the right caterer can make or break the experience. We've scoured the local scene to bring you five standout services that deliver exceptional
The Columbus Catering Landscape
Columbus's catering industry is a vibrant mix of long-standing family businesses and innovative newcomers. The market is driven by a demand for personalized menus, dietary flexibility, and seamless event execution. Many top caterers now offer everything from drop-off corporate lunches to fully staffed, luxury wedding receptions. The common thread? A commitment to using quality ingredients and providing service that lets you enjoy your own event. This competitive field means you have more choices than ever to find a caterer that matches your specific needs and budget.
How We Ranked the Best
To create this list, we evaluated each caterer on four key criteria: menu creativity and customization, service quality and professionalism, years of experience and reputation, and overall value for the price. We looked for businesses that not only deliver great food but also make the planning process easy and stress-free. Each caterer was assessed on their ability to handle events of different sizes and styles, from casual gatherings to formal galas.
Here's a quick look at how the top five caterers stack up against each other, highlighting their unique strengths and best-use cases.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Together & Company Events and Catering | Full-service weddings and corporate events |
| Catering By Scott | Flexible menus and dietary accommodations |
| Carfagna's Catering | Italian-inspired menus and family-style events |
| Full Service Event Catering | Rachelsfamous.com | Columbus | Luxury, scratch-made event catering |
| Milo's Catering | Affordable full-service and corporate catering |
Deep Dive: The Top 5 Columbus Caterers
#1 Together & Company Events and Catering
A screenshot of the Together & Company Events and Catering website.
With over 25 years of experience, Together & Company is a powerhouse in Columbus catering. They specialize in creating personalized menus for everything from small corporate luncheons to grand wedding receptions. Their team of chefs and planners works closely with you to accommodate all tastes and dietary needs. They also operate two award-winning event venues, High Line Car House and The Fives, both honored as 'Best of Columbus' Wedding Venues. Whether at their venues or yours, they promise extraordinary flavors and impeccable service. This is the go-to choice for a full-service, stress-free experience.
#2 Catering By Scott
A screenshot of the Catering By Scott website.
Catering By Scott brings over 37 years of family-owned experience to events across Ohio. They focus on fresh, flexible menus and personal service that makes planning feel easy. Every menu is built around quality ingredients and thoughtful presentation, with options for different tastes, dietary needs, and event styles, including gluten-free choices. Nationally recognized by The Knot and WeddingWire, they cater to events of all sizes, from formal galas to casual company picnics. Their team aims to make you feel confident from the first call to the last plate cleared. It's a reliable choice for fresh, generous catering that feels made for the moment.
#3 Carfagna's Catering
A screenshot of the Carfagna's Catering website.
Carfagna's Catering is a family-run business that has been serving Central Ohio for over 30 years. They pride themselves on homemade, quality catered meals, from Italian pastas and specialty stations to boxed lunches and wedding packages. Their team guides you through every step, from menu selection to coordinating flowers, music, and lights. They handle events of all sizes, including weddings, business events, and special occasions like birthdays and graduations. Whether you pick up or want full delivery and staffing, they make planning easy. It's a warm, family-oriented option for those who want a personal touch.
#4 Full Service Event Catering | Rachelsfamous.com | Columbus
A screenshot of the Rachelsfamous.com website.
Rachel's Famous is a luxury event caterer based in Columbus, specializing in scratch-made original recipes and gracious service. They are committed to fulfilling the unique vision of each event, with core values of satisfaction, excellence, and dedication. Their focus is on providing a high-end dining experience that feels both personal and polished. While they are newer to the scene compared to some competitors, their dedication to original recipes and luxury service sets them apart. They are an excellent choice for clients who want a bespoke, chef-driven menu. Contact them at 614-980-9712 or rachelsfamous@gmail.com to discuss your event.
#5 Milo's Catering
A screenshot of the Milo's Catering website.
Milo's Catering has been a respected name in Columbus for over 25 years, known for combining exceptional food with courteous, professional service at affordable prices. They offer a range of options including corporate catering, delivery drop-off, full-service events, and weddings. Their team focuses on making quality catering accessible without sacrificing service. They also have their own venues for events, adding convenience for clients. For a reliable, experienced caterer that balances quality and value, Milo's is a solid pick. It's a great option for budget-conscious planners who still want a professional touch.
How to Pick Your Perfect Caterer
Start by defining the style and size of your event. A luxury wedding might call for a full-service caterer like Together & Company or Rachel's Famous, while a corporate lunch could be perfectly handled by Catering By Scott or Milo's. Consider your menu preferences: if you love Italian, Carfagna's is a natural fit. Always ask about customization for dietary restrictions. Finally, read reviews and ask for references to ensure the caterer's service matches your expectations. Don't be afraid to request a tasting to confirm the food is as good as it sounds.
Streamline Your Event Planning
Once you've chosen a caterer, use a simple workflow to stay organized. First, create a shared digital folder for contracts, menus, and invoices. Second, set up a timeline with key milestones like the tasting date, final headcount, and delivery time. Third, use a checklist app to track tasks like confirming dietary needs and arranging rentals. This keeps everything in one place and reduces last-minute stress, letting you focus on enjoying your event.
Your Next Great Meal Awaits
Columbus's catering scene is rich with talent, offering something for every taste and budget. Whether you choose the established excellence of Together & Company, the family warmth of Carfagna's, or the luxury originality of Rachel's Famous, you're in good hands. The key is to match the caterer's strengths with your event's needs. Take your time, ask questions, and trust your palate. The perfect caterer is out there, ready to turn your event into an unforgettable experience.