Planning an event in Columbus, Ohio, means you have a wealth of catering options. But with so many choices, finding the perfect partner for your wedding, corporate gathering, or special celebration can feel overwhelming. I've dug into the local scene
The Columbus Catering Landscape
Columbus, Ohio, boasts a vibrant and competitive catering industry, with companies ranging from family-run operations to full-service event powerhouses. Many caterers here have decades of experience, offering everything from intimate dinners to large-scale corporate events. The common thread among the best is a commitment to fresh, innovative menus and personalized service that adapts to your unique needs. Whether you're looking for classic comfort food or modern culinary creations, Columbus caterers are equipped to impress your guests.
How We Ranked the Best
To create this list, I evaluated each caterer based on four key criteria: experience and reputation, menu variety and customization, service flexibility (from drop-off to full-service), and overall client feedback. I also considered their ability to handle events of all sizes and their unique differentiators, such as event planning or rental services. The result is a curated selection of caterers that excel in making your event stress-free and delicious.
Here's a quick look at the top five Columbus caterers, highlighting what each does best.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Catering By Scott | Flexible, family-owned catering for any event size |
| Carfagna's Catering | Italian-inspired menus and full wedding planning |
| Steven's Catering | Classic dishes and full-service events for up to 300 guests |
| Catering Services | Milano Creative Catering | Full-service event planning with rentals and bar service |
| Milo's Catering | Affordable, professional catering with venue options |
Deep Dive: The Top 5 Columbus Caterers
#1 Catering By Scott
A screenshot of the Catering By Scott website.
Catering By Scott has been a trusted name in Central Ohio for over 37 years, earning national recognition from The Knot and WeddingWire. They focus on fresh, flexible menus that can accommodate dietary needs, including gluten-free options, and their service ranges from intimate gatherings to large corporate events. The team prides itself on making planning simple and the final result memorable, with a 100 percent family-owned approach. Whether you need a formal dinner or a casual BBQ, they tailor every menu to your event style.
#2 Carfagna's Catering
A screenshot of the Carfagna's Catering website.
Carfagna's Catering brings over 30 years of family tradition to Central Ohio, specializing in homemade Italian cuisine and custom menus for weddings, business events, and special occasions. They offer a wide range of services, from boxed lunches to fully staffed receptions, and even help with venue selection and decor. Their Italian Wedding Dinner Package is a standout, and they emphasize a 'from our family to yours' philosophy. Clients appreciate their guidance through every step of the planning process.
#3 Steven's Catering
A screenshot of the Steven's Catering website.
Steven's Catering, opened in 2002 by Chef/Owner Steven P. Sims, is a full-service event specialist serving Central Ohio. They handle gatherings from 10 to 300 guests, offering breakfast, luncheons, dinners, and wedding receptions with a focus on quality interpretations of classic dishes. Their experienced staff is praised for creating culinary masterpieces, and they also provide bartending services. Client testimonials highlight the phenomenal food and service, especially for events like weddings and corporate functions.
#4 Catering Services | Milano Creative Catering
A screenshot of the Milano Creative Catering website.
Milano Creative Catering is a full-service catering and event company based in Columbus, Ohio, with over 47 years of experience. They offer extensive menus, bar services, complete event planning, and rentals for linens, cutlery, and decor. Their team handles setup, service, and cleanup to ensure stress-free events at venues, homes, offices, or unique locations. They are described as the most trusted caterer in Columbus, with unmatched experience in designing unique events.
#5 Milo's Catering
A screenshot of the Milo's Catering website.
Milo's Catering has been a respected caterer in Columbus for over 25 years, known for combining exceptional food with courteous, professional service at affordable prices. They offer corporate catering, delivery drop-off, full-service events, and weddings, and they have their own venues for hosting. Their team focuses on making every event seamless, whether it's a simple lunch delivery or a grand celebration. Clients appreciate their experience and reliability for events of all sizes.
How to Choose the Right Caterer for Your Event
Start by defining the type of service you need: drop-off, delivery, or full-service with setup and staff. Consider your guest count and whether the caterer can handle it. Look at menu variety and if they can accommodate dietary restrictions. Read reviews and ask for references to gauge reliability. Finally, ensure they fit your budget and style, whether that's formal plated dinners or casual buffets.
Streamline Your Catering Search
To simplify your decision, create a shortlist of caterers based on your event type and size. Use online ordering systems or request quotes through their websites to compare pricing quickly. Many caterers offer sample menus or tasting events, so schedule those to narrow down your top choices. Automate follow-ups with a simple spreadsheet to track responses and availability.
Your Next Event Starts Here
Columbus is home to an impressive array of caterers, each with unique strengths. From the family-owned warmth of Catering By Scott to the Italian traditions of Carfagna's, and the full-service expertise of Milano Creative Catering, you have options that can turn any gathering into a success. Use this guide to match your needs with the right partner, and you'll be well on your way to an unforgettable event.