Planning an event in Columbus, Ohio, and feeling overwhelmed by catering choices? You need a team that delivers delicious food and flawless service, whether it's an intimate dinner or a large corporate gathering. We've tasted, researched, and ranked the top
The Columbus Catering Scene
Columbus boasts a vibrant and diverse catering industry, with companies ranging from family-run operations to full-service event powerhouses. These caterers are known for their flexibility, offering everything from drop-off lunches to fully staffed weddings. The best in the business focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and personalized menus that cater to a variety of dietary needs. Whether you're planning a micro wedding or a company picnic, Columbus caterers bring professionalism and culinary creativity to the table.
How We Ranked the Best
We evaluated each caterer based on menu variety and customization, service options (drop-off, full-service, to-go), years of experience, client reviews, and overall value. We also considered their ability to handle events of different sizes and styles, from intimate gatherings to large-scale celebrations. The final rankings reflect a balance of culinary excellence, reliability, and customer satisfaction.
Here's a quick look at how the top five Columbus caterers stack up against each other.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Catering By Scott | Overall versatility and experience |
| Milo's Catering | Affordable full-service catering |
| Steven's Catering | Creative menus and classic dishes |
| Bleu & Fig | Intimate events and micro weddings |
| Carfagna's Catering | Italian cuisine and family-style events |
Detailed Reviews of Columbus's Top 5 Caterers
#1 Catering By Scott
A screenshot of the Catering By Scott website.
Catering By Scott has been a trusted name in Central Ohio for over 37 years, earning national recognition from The Knot and WeddingWire. They specialize in fresh, flexible menus that can be customized for any event, from corporate luncheons to weddings. Their team focuses on making planning simple and stress-free, with options for gluten-free and other dietary needs. Whether you need a formal dinner or a casual BBQ, they deliver quality ingredients and thoughtful presentation. Clients consistently praise their personal service and ability to handle events of all sizes. For a caterer that combines experience with a personal touch, Catering By Scott is a top choice.
#2 Milo's Catering
A screenshot of the Milo's Catering website.
Milo's Catering brings over 25 years of experience to the Columbus catering scene, offering a range of services from drop-off delivery to full-service events. They are known for combining exceptional food with courteous, professional service at affordable prices. Their seasonal menus and venue partnerships make them a popular choice for weddings and corporate events. Milo's has built a reputation for reliability and consistency, making them a go-to for many local hosts. If you value a seasoned caterer with a straightforward approach, Milo's is a strong contender.
#3 Steven's Catering
A screenshot of the Steven's Catering website.
Steven's Catering has been a full-service event specialist in Central Ohio since 2002, led by Chef/Owner Steven P. Sims. They cater to gatherings of all sizes, from breakfast meetings to wedding receptions for up to 300 guests. Their menu features both classic dishes and innovative culinary creations, earning rave reviews for items like their deviled eggs. The team is known for experienced staff and a commitment to making every event memorable. For a caterer that blends tradition with creativity, Steven's Catering delivers.
#4 Bleu & Fig
A screenshot of the Bleu & Fig website.
Bleu & Fig is a full-service catering company and event space based in Columbus, Ohio, offering chef-curated menus for gatherings at home, off-site, or in their intimate venue. They provide seamless service from drop-off to on-site catering, with professional staff and polished presentation for occasions like showers, weddings, and corporate events. The business has received strong positive reviews for its delicious food, attentive service, and ability to elevate events. Their event space is designed for micro weddings and intimate celebrations, paired with seasonal menus and attentive service. Bleu & Fig also partners with local venues that share their commitment to thoughtful design. For a caterer that combines a beautiful space with exceptional food, Bleu & Fig is a standout choice.
#5 Carfagna's Catering
A screenshot of the Carfagna's Catering website.
Carfagna's Catering has been a family-run business for over 30 years, proudly serving Central Ohio with homemade, quality catered meals. They offer a wide range of menus, from Italian specialties to party trays and boxed lunches, making them a versatile option for any occasion. Their team guides clients through every step, from menu selection to coordinating flowers and music for weddings. Carfagna's is especially known for their Italian dishes and ability to handle large events with ease. For a caterer that feels like family and delivers consistent quality, Carfagna's is a reliable choice.
How to Choose the Right Caterer for You
Start by defining the size and style of your event. For large weddings or corporate galas, consider experienced full-service caterers like Catering By Scott or Milo's. If you're planning an intimate micro wedding or a small gathering, Bleu & Fig's dedicated event space and personalized service might be perfect. Think about your preferred cuisine: Carfagna's excels at Italian, while Steven's offers creative classics. Always read recent reviews and ask about menu customization and dietary accommodations. Finally, request a tasting to ensure the food matches your vision.
Streamline Your Event Planning
Once you've chosen your caterer, use online ordering systems and event management tools to simplify the process. Many caterers, like Carfagna's, offer online menus and ordering for quick pick-up or delivery. For larger events, create a shared digital checklist with your caterer to track menu selections, guest counts, and timelines. Automating reminders and confirmations can help ensure everything runs smoothly on the big day.
Your Perfect Event Starts Here
Columbus is home to an impressive array of caterers, each with its own strengths and specialties. Whether you need the versatility of Catering By Scott, the affordability of Milo's, the creativity of Steven's, the intimate charm of Bleu & Fig, or the family tradition of Carfagna's, there's a perfect match for your event. Take the time to explore their menus, read reviews, and schedule tastings. With the right caterer, your event will be deliciously memorable.