Beyond the Resume: WriteWise on Crafting College Essays That Reveal How You Think
When students sit down to write their college essays, they often follow the same well-worn advice: write about what you're passionate about, show your achievements, and make sure your voice stands out. But according to Vedant and Manushri, co-founders of WriteWise, that approach can lead to essays that read like resumes rather than reflections of how a student thinks.
In this interview, the two co-founders share insights from their work with students and explain why the most common essay advice can miss the mark.
When Standard Advice Fails
Vedant recalls a student who followed the classic "write about your passion" guidance. His Common App essay focused on tennis—a sport he'd played since childhood and in which he'd competed in tournaments. "It read like a long-form version of his tennis resume," Vedant says. For the student and his parents, tennis was such a weighty part of his resume that the essay had to be about it. But Vedant and Manushri challenged that thinking. "His activity list already covers tennis. The essay is the one place admissions officers get to hear how he thinks."
The student was applying to study Physics and had worked on competitions designing space settlements for life beyond Earth. That was what genuinely excited him. But written as a description of the competition, it would have been impressive and forgettable. So they asked a different question: "if you had to leave Earth for good, what would you take with you?" The student picked a deck of cards, his father's watch, and a photo with his sister—each item reflecting something he values. That became the essay.
For both of them, the key is whether the student is excited to share the story. "Because that shows up in your writing," Vedant says. "You can see it in the words you choose, the tone, the level of detail."
The Missing Piece: Framing
While much of the online advice focuses on hooks, editing, and topic selection, Vedant and Manushri believe the most overlooked element is framing—the lens through which the essay is written. "On the surface, it looks like the student is writing from their own perspective," Vedant explains. "But most of the time, the essay is framed with the college as the focus. They start from the outside. They research what a college wants, build a picture of the ideal applicant, and try to become that shape on the page." The result, he says, reads like a pitch, not a person.
Instead, they advocate for self-discovery first. "Most students we meet are convinced nothing interesting has ever happened to them," Vedant notes. Abstract questions like "what makes you unique?" don't help. Concrete ones do: What do you do in the first ten minutes after you get home? What have you explained to a friend more than three times? What argument do you keep having with your parents? What do you know a lot about that has nothing to do with your college application?
This approach informed the creation of Mara, WriteWise's AI brainstorming tool. "She works as a conversation, not a worksheet," Vedant says. "She asks one question at a time and follows up on the answer the student almost skipped. More often than not, it's a story they've always known but simply forgotten."
Deciding Too Quickly
When students start their essays, they often rush to write about their most impressive achievement. Vedant describes the unspoken thought process: "I've spent five years on this. I've won awards, I was made captain, and it's what makes my resume strong... If I want to emphasize it, I need to write my essay about it." But he warns that this leads to essays that blend together. "After a while, no matter what the activity is or what rank was earned, it reads as one more essay about an achievement. Lost in the herd."
The real story, he says, is usually hiding inside the achievement. One student ran the Devil's Circuit at 16 and wrote about how brutal it was. Almost in passing, he mentioned spending half the race watching the people around him and figuring out who needed help but wouldn't ask. "That was the essay," Vedant says. "The race wasn't the point. What he noticed during it was."
Before committing to a topic, Vedant and Manushri suggest students check: Could another applicant send this exact essay with their name swapped in? Does it show how you think, or only what happened to you? What's the takeaway? If it's "never give up" or "hard work pays off," keep asking "so what?" until you find something only you would have taken away.
They also see students rush the "why us" essay, writing about world-class faculty and strong alumni networks—phrases admissions officers have read a million times. "A good 'why us' essay is a marriage between you and the college," Vedant says. "Start with what you've already done, then find what that school has that fits it and would push you further." That requires real research for every school, which is why many students skip it. WriteWise's College Research tool helps by going through a college's pages and matching them to the student's resume. "They still write the essay themselves, but now they have something real to say."
For more information on college essays and admissions, visit WriteWise.
Key Takeaways
- The essay is not the place to repeat your activity list; it's where admissions officers learn how you think.
- Framing matters: write from your own perspective, not through the lens of what you think a college wants.
- Use concrete questions to uncover stories you've forgotten.
- Before settling on a topic, check if it reveals your unique way of thinking or just another achievement.
- For "why us" essays, do real research to connect your experiences with specific opportunities at each school.
