Attribution Reality Check: Jim Hollis on Channel Measurement That Fits the Business
Jim Hollis has spent more than 20 years in B2B SaaS and healthcare technology, leading growth and demand generation at companies including NextGen Healthcare, IQVIA and Hayes, Inc. He is now a partner at Strivan Marketing, where he helps B2B companies build marketing that turns into real pipeline. We asked him three questions about channel attribution, and his answers point to a consistent theme: the model matters less than the data and the organizational discipline behind it.
When the usual advice doesn't fit
Hollis identified three situations where standard channel attribution guidance breaks down. The first is a long sales cycle. At NextGen Healthcare, he sold six- and seven-figure deals to health systems with cycles running 6 to 18 months. "The channel that gets last-touch credit for a deal may not be the one that deserves all of it," he said. "A conversation at a trade show a year earlier might have started the whole thing." Attribution models that cover the full lifecycle from lead to customer are the toughest to set up, and that is where generic advice falls short.
The second is a short list of target accounts. At Hayes, health plans were a main segment. "When you already know exactly who your target customers are, the question isn't really which channel is working," Hollis said. The shift is to an account-based strategy with a multi-touch attribution model built around those specific accounts.
The third is growth from existing customers. "Getting a new customer and getting an existing customer to upsell, cross-sell or renew are two different playbooks," he said. Judging renewal and expansion marketing by the same yardstick as new-customer acquisition leads to wrong conclusions about both.
What most advice leaves out
Hollis listed several things that keep coming up in these situations. The first is that the data is usually the problem, not the model. "You have to fix the CRM before you pick a model," he said. That means getting the whole company on board with how results get tracked and measured, with every team that touches a customer documenting what happens in the CRM.
Alignment has to go past marketing and sales. "Customer service and other teams need to be part of it too," Hollis said. The whole organization should speak the same language and understand why things get entered the way they do. "Then when questions come up, and they will, you can talk them through logically instead of turning them into a turf war over who gets credit."
Not every channel creates a direct line to a lead, but they all play a part. "Branded search and 'direct' traffic often get credit for demand that was created somewhere else," he said. "Nobody Googles your company name out of nowhere." A webinar, a peer recommendation, a podcast, an ad they scrolled past three times, an AI answer: something sent them there. If the team doesn't understand that, the channels doing the early work will always look like they aren't pulling their weight.
Hollis also advocates asking customers directly, but in a way you can report on. "A 'How did you hear about us?' question on your forms will tell you things no tracking pixel will," he said. Give people a clear set of options and maybe an open text field, because a wide-open text box with no guidance gives answers you can't roll up into a report.
Finally, platform changes can break your history. "Before you move to a new platform, document anything and everything you can about how data was tracked," Hollis said. That goes for changes to the platform you're already on, too. When someone asks six months later why a metric suddenly jumped or dropped, you'll have a likely answer instead of a guess.
Decisions made too quickly
The biggest mistake Hollis sees is killing a channel too early, usually because it's being measured the wrong way. "Before a channel or campaign launches, you need to be clear about what it's meant to do and how it will be judged," he said. He has seen companies shut down a channel because it wasn't producing enough leads, when it was never supposed to produce leads in the first place. "Judging a brand campaign on lead count is like judging your caddie on how far he hits his driver."
Second, people treat talking to sales and customers as something you do right before you move budget. "It shouldn't be a one-time check," Hollis said. Talk with your sales team every week and every month, and meet with customers regularly. Over time those stories add up to a narrative that helps shape and adjust marketing strategy.
Third, they expect perfect attribution. "You'll never get it," Hollis said. Everyone on the executive team, across every department, needs to understand that. "The goal is to be directionally right and consistent, then make decisions you're willing to revisit."
For teams trying to sort out which channels are actually bringing in customers, Hollis said that is a lot of what they do at Strivan Marketing. More about his work is available at jimhollismarketing.com.
Practical takeaways
- Fix the CRM and get company-wide agreement on tracking before choosing an attribution model.
- Extend alignment beyond marketing and sales to customer service and other customer-facing teams.
- Recognize that branded search and direct traffic often capture demand created elsewhere.
- Ask customers how they heard about you, using structured options that can be reported on.
- Document tracking changes before and during platform migrations.
- Define what each channel is meant to do before launch, and judge it on that purpose.
- Treat attribution as directional and consistent, not perfect, and be willing to revisit decisions.
