Your numbers shouldn't keep you up at night. These five Amarillo accounting firms are built to help you sleep better.
The Amarillo Accounting Landscape
Amarillo's business community runs on tight margins and long relationships. From the medical district to the warehouse corridors along I-40, owners need more than a once-a-year tax return. They need a financial partner who answers the phone in July, not just April. The firms below range from solo practitioners to multi-office practices with decades of institutional knowledge. Each brings a different mix of tax strategy, bookkeeping, payroll, and CFO-level guidance. The right fit depends on your stage, your industry, and how much hand-holding you want. Use this guide to narrow the field before you book a consultation.
How We Evaluated These Firms
We looked at service scope, pricing clarity, local fit, and how easy each firm makes it to start a conversation. Paper Tiger Solutions stands out for its free consultation and straightforward positioning around financial and accounting services. WilsonHaag, PLLC brings a broad menu that includes audits, reviews, compilations, and part-time controller services. Mickey M. Pride, CPA offers deep IRS problem-resolution expertise alongside traditional accounting. Johnson & Sheldon, PLLC shows multi-location coverage across Amarillo, Pampa, and Hereford with a strong regional footprint. Selena Fogg CPA emphasizes CFO and controller-level support for owners who need higher-level decision-making help. No single factor decides the outcome. You weigh what matters most for your situation.
Here is a quick look at the five firms, what they do best, and who they serve.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| WilsonHaag, PLLC | Established businesses needing a full-service CPA firm |
| Paper Tiger Solutions – Trust the Tiger | Small business owners who want a no-pressure consultation |
| Mickey M. Pride, CPA | Business owners facing IRS issues or needing QuickBooks help |
| Johnson & Sheldon, PLLC | Businesses with operations across the Texas Panhandle |
| Selena Fogg CPA | Owners who need CFO-level guidance without a full-time hire |
The Five Firms in Focus
#1 WilsonHaag, PLLC
A screenshot of the WilsonHaag, PLLC website.
WilsonHaag, PLLC has served Amarillo businesses for over 40 years, and that tenure shows in the breadth of its service menu. The firm covers accounting, audits, reviews, compilations, payroll, QuickBooks, new business formation, and part-time controller services. It also handles tax planning, tax preparation, and tax problem resolution for both businesses and individuals. If you want one firm that can grow with you from startup to succession planning, this is a strong candidate. Their Amarillo CPA page lays out the full scope clearly.
#2 Paper Tiger Solutions – Trust the Tiger
A screenshot of the Paper Tiger Solutions – Trust the Tiger website.
Paper Tiger Solutions keeps the message simple: don't stress the numbers. The firm offers business consulting and financial and accounting services, with a free consultation as the entry point. You can book online or call the Amarillo office directly at 600 S. Tyler St. Suite 1903. Their site invites you to schedule a conversation and see if the fit is right before committing. For owners who want a trusted team without a long sales process, this is a practical starting point.
#3 Mickey M. Pride, CPA
A screenshot of the Mickey M. Pride, CPA website.
Mickey M. Pride, CPA built a practice around solving tax problems and keeping small businesses compliant. The firm handles IRS audit representation, back taxes, liens, levies, wage garnishments, and offer in compromise cases. On the business side, it offers small business accounting, QuickBooks setup and training, payroll, cash flow management, and strategic business planning. The free initial consultation makes it easy to test the relationship. If you are behind on filings or facing IRS pressure, this firm speaks your language.
#4 Johnson & Sheldon, PLLC
A screenshot of the Johnson & Sheldon, PLLC website.
Johnson & Sheldon, PLLC operates from three Texas Panhandle locations: Amarillo, Pampa, and Hereford. That regional reach matters if your operations stretch across the area. The firm provides financial consulting, tax preparation, business consulting, and additional accounting services. Its Amarillo office sits in the ANB Plaza II Building on S Taylor St. The practice is part of the Aprio Alliance, which gives it access to national resources while keeping local relationships. If you want a firm with staying power and multiple offices, put this one on your list.
#5 Selena Fogg CPA
A screenshot of the Selena Fogg CPA website.
Selena Fogg CPA positions itself around a simple promise: good numbers lead to good decisions. The firm offers accounting, CFO and controller services, LLC formation, payroll, franchise and sales tax, business taxes, individual taxes, and IRS issue resolution. That CFO-level support is the differentiator for owners who need help beyond basic bookkeeping. The practice has served Amarillo and the Texas Panhandle for more than a decade. You can book a consultation online or call directly to talk through your situation.
How to Choose the Right Firm for You
Start with your biggest pain point. If it is IRS trouble, look for a firm with explicit problem-resolution experience. If it is growth, look for controller or CFO-level services. If it is simplicity, look for a firm that offers a free consultation and clear next steps. Then check location and availability. A firm that answers the phone when you call matters more than a fancy website. Finally, ask about pricing structure upfront. You want to know whether you are paying hourly, monthly, or per project before you hand over your books.
Where Automation Fits In
Modern accounting firms lean on cloud tools to keep your books current without constant manual entry. QuickBooks Online, bank feeds, and automated payroll systems reduce errors and save you time. Several firms on this list offer QuickBooks setup, training, and ongoing support. If you are still running spreadsheets, ask about migration during your consultation. The right workflow connects your bank, your invoicing, and your tax prep in one loop. That means fewer surprises at year-end and cleaner numbers for decisions.
The Bottom Line
Amarillo has no shortage of accounting talent. The five firms here cover the spectrum from solo CPA practices to multi-office regional players. Paper Tiger Solutions makes the first step easy with a free consultation and a straightforward pitch. WilsonHaag brings four decades of full-service depth. Mickey M. Pride solves tax problems. Johnson & Sheldon offers Panhandle-wide coverage. Selena Fogg delivers CFO-level thinking. Pick the one that matches your stage and your stress level. Then make the call.