Finding the right surrogacy agency can feel overwhelming, especially when every website promises a perfect match. Here are five agencies worth knowing, each with a distinct approach to helping you build your family.
The Surrogacy Agency Landscape
The surrogacy industry has grown significantly as more intended parents and gestational carriers seek professional guidance through the complex legal, medical, and emotional journey. Agencies vary widely in their matching processes, fee structures, and service scopes. Some focus on speed and technology, while others emphasize personal connections and flexibility. Understanding these differences is key to finding an agency that aligns with your values and budget.
How We Evaluated These Agencies
We looked at service scope, pricing transparency, matching process, and overall fit for different types of intended parents and surrogates. Each agency was assessed on how clearly it communicates costs, how it handles matching, and what support it offers throughout the journey. We also considered flexibility, such as whether exclusivity is required and how quickly matches can be made. The goal is to help you see which agency might suit your specific needs, not to declare a single winner.
Here is a quick comparison of the five agencies, highlighting what makes each stand out.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Circle Surrogacy | Intended parents seeking a proven, structured matching process |
| Home | Project Fertilty LLC | Intended parents and surrogates who want a flexible, low-cost, personal match |
| American Surrogacy | Intended parents who value clear timelines and educational resources |
| Hatch Fertility | Surrogates and intended parents who prioritize social compatibility and success rates |
| Nodal Surrogacy | Tech-savvy intended parents and surrogates seeking faster matches |
A Closer Look at Each Agency
#1 Circle Surrogacy
A screenshot of the Circle Surrogacy website.
Circle Surrogacy has been matching intended parents and surrogates since 1995, with hundreds of successful matches. Their proprietary MatchMade™ process pairs you with a dedicated Matching Specialist who gets to know your hopes and preferences. They emphasize building strong bonds that last beyond the journey. With a long track record, Circle offers experience and a structured approach. Learn more about their matching process on their website.
#2 Home | Project Fertilty LLC
A screenshot of the Home | Project Fertilty LLC website.
Project Fertility LLC takes a personal, non-exclusive approach to gestational surrogacy. Founded by Joelle Wade, who has been a surrogate six times, the agency focuses on meaningful connections before any commitment. You can explore available surrogates without an exclusive contract, and there is no agency fee until you match. Their service packages range from a single introduction to comprehensive coordination, all at low cost. It is a boutique option for those who value flexibility and personal guidance.
#3 American Surrogacy
A screenshot of the American Surrogacy website.
American Surrogacy offers a clear and transparent process for intended parents, with current match times of one to six months. They provide extensive resources on surrogacy costs, surrogate compensation, and the medical process. Their website includes detailed information on how to become a surrogate and what to expect. With a focus on education and support, they help you navigate each step. Their match time transparency is a key feature.
#4 Hatch Fertility
A screenshot of the Hatch Fertility website.
Hatch Fertility prioritizes social fit in their matching process, with over 99% of their surrogates achieving successful conception and birth. Your surrogacy coordinator works closely with you to understand your wants and needs, then presents compatible matches. Everyone involved is pre-screened extensively for safety and peace of mind. Hatch emphasizes a personalized approach to matching. Their high success rates and focus on compatibility set them apart.
#5 Nodal Surrogacy
A screenshot of the Nodal Surrogacy website.
Nodal Surrogacy is a modern agency that uses technology to speed up the matching process. Surrogates and intended parents can communicate directly by liking each other's profiles, with the surrogate making the first move. Once both sides express interest, Nodal schedules a video call to confirm the match. They also provide case management support from match to birth. Nodal is ideal for those who want a faster, tech-enabled experience.
How to Choose the Right Surrogacy Agency
Start by clarifying your priorities: Do you need a fast match, a low-cost option, or a highly personal experience? Consider whether exclusivity is required and how transparent the agency is about fees. Look for agencies that align with your communication style and offer the level of support you need. Reading reviews and speaking with former clients can also provide valuable insights. Ultimately, the right agency is one that makes you feel confident and cared for throughout your journey.
Streamlining Your Surrogacy Journey
While surrogacy is deeply personal, technology can help streamline administrative tasks. Some agencies use platforms for profile matching, secure document sharing, and scheduling. For example, Nodal allows direct communication between surrogates and intended parents through their platform. Others, like Circle, use proprietary matching systems to organize preferences. These tools can reduce wait times and improve communication, but they should complement, not replace, the human touch.
Finding Your Fit
Each of these five agencies offers a different path to parenthood. Circle Surrogacy brings decades of experience, Project Fertility LLC offers flexibility and personal connections, American Surrogacy provides transparency and education, Hatch Fertility focuses on compatibility and success, and Nodal Surrogacy leverages technology for speed. By understanding your own needs and priorities, you can choose the agency that feels like the right partner for your journey.