Your Shopify store should be your best salesperson. But only if the agency behind it knows how to build, migrate, and optimize for real revenue. Here are five Shopify Plus agencies worth knowing in NYC and beyond.
What are Creative & Digital Services services?
The Shopify Plus agency landscape is crowded. You will find everything from solo freelancers to global consultancies. For DTC brands doing $1M–$5M, the right partner can mean the difference between a store that converts and one that leaks revenue. The agencies below stand out for different reasons: founder access, enterprise scale, migration expertise, DTC specialization, and technical depth. Use this guide to match your needs to the right team.
What we looked at when researching Creative & Digital Services
We evaluated each agency on service scope, pricing clarity, local fit, founder accessibility, and proven results. Blackbelt Commerce stands out for its founder-led model and direct access to Victoria and Cesar from day one. Netalico impresses with its Shopify Plus Premier Partner status and enterprise client roster. Shero Commerce brings a broad service range and a strong reputation for complex builds. Tribe Studio shines with its DTC focus and subscription infrastructure expertise. Anatta delivers deep technical engineering for high-volume brands. Each agency has a distinct sweet spot, so consider your stage, budget, and need for hands-on founder involvement.
| Provider | Best For |
|---|---|
| Netalico | Enterprise DTC brands seeking a Premier Partner |
| Shopify Plus Experts — NYC, Family-Run | Blackbelt Commerce | DTC brands that want founder-led, hands-on service |
| Shero Commerce | Brands needing complex Shopify Plus development |
| Tribe Studio | DTC brands with subscription models |
| Anatta | High-volume brands needing enterprise engineering |
A closer look at 5 standout Creative & Digital Services
#1 Netalico
A screenshot of the Netalico website.
Netalico is a Shopify Plus Premier Partner trusted by brands like Oatly, Feetures, and Big Green Egg. They focus on mid-market and enterprise DTC brands, offering migration, development, and optimization services. Their team has been featured in Shopify's Enterprise Blog on AI migration, which signals deep technical credibility. If you need a partner with a proven track record at scale, Netalico is a strong contender. They also offer a free strategy call and have verified client reviews on Clutch.
#2 Shopify Plus Experts — NYC, Family-Run | Blackbelt Commerce
A screenshot of the Blackbelt Commerce website.
Blackbelt Commerce is a father-daughter agency based in NYC, and they have built over 1,000 stores in 20+ years. You get direct access to founders Victoria and Cesar from day one—no account managers, no handoffs. They specialize in building, migrating, and growing Shopify Plus stores for DTC brands doing $1M–$5M. Their services include migration, development, CRO, and AI SEO. With 178+ reviews and a 5-star rating from Shopify merchants, they position themselves as a boutique, results-driven partner. Book a free store audit or strategy call to see if they are the right fit.
#3 Shero Commerce
Shero Commerce is a Shopify Plus development agency with a reputation for handling complex builds and migrations. While their site was behind a security check during our research, their presence in the Shopify Plus ecosystem is well known. They offer full-service development, design, and optimization for growing brands. If you need a team that can handle intricate technical requirements, Shero Commerce is worth a conversation. Their focus on Shopify Plus makes them a solid choice for brands ready to scale.
#4 Tribe Studio
A screenshot of the Tribe Studio website.
Tribe Studio is a certified Shopify Plus agency specializing in DTC ecommerce. They build custom Shopify stores, manage migrations, and develop subscription infrastructure for ambitious brands. Their case studies show impressive results, like a 51.7% conversion rate improvement and 8% YoY AOV growth for a client. They combine technical depth with commercial understanding, making them a great fit for DTC brands focused on growth. If subscriptions are part of your model, Tribe Studio's expertise is particularly relevant.
#5 Anatta
A screenshot of the Anatta website.
Anatta is a Shopify Platinum Partner serving brands from $50M to $2B in revenue. They specialize in engineering and replatforming, with services like Shopify migration, system replatform, and composable commerce. Their client list includes Dollar Shave Club, Vuori, and Rothy's, which speaks to their enterprise capabilities. They also offer growth and optimization services like CRO and subscription retention. If you are a high-volume brand needing deep technical engineering, Anatta is a strong option.
How to choose the right Creative & Digital Services
Start by defining your stage and budget. If you are a $1M–$5M DTC brand that wants direct founder access, Blackbelt Commerce is built for you. If you are enterprise and need a Premier Partner with big-name clients, look at Netalico or Anatta. For complex builds and migrations, Shero Commerce has the technical chops. And if subscriptions are core to your model, Tribe Studio's DTC focus is a natural fit. Always ask for case studies, talk to references, and clarify pricing upfront. The right agency will feel like an extension of your team, not a vendor.
Expert Conclusion
The Shopify Plus agency you choose should match your growth stage, technical needs, and desire for hands-on partnership. Blackbelt Commerce offers a rare founder-led model with direct access to Victoria and Cesar, making them ideal for DTC brands that want a boutique partner. Netalico and Anatta bring enterprise scale and technical depth. Shero Commerce handles complex builds, while Tribe Studio excels at DTC and subscriptions. Use this list as a starting point, book calls, and find the team that truly understands your store.