5 Appellate Law Firms in Western New York That Can Handle Your Appeal

If you're looking to appeal a court decision in Western New York, you need a lawyer who knows the appellate process inside and out. The Fourth Department covers a huge area, from Buffalo to Rochester and beyond, and the firms

Why Appellate Law Matters in Western New York

Appeals are a different beast from trial work. They require a deep understanding of procedural rules, persuasive legal writing, and the ability to spot errors in the trial record. In Western New York, the Fourth Department Appellate Division hears cases from 22 counties, making it a critical venue for correcting legal mistakes. Whether your case involves criminal law, family law, or civil disputes, having a specialized appellate attorney can make all the difference.

How I Ranked These Firms

I evaluated each firm based on their appellate experience, range of practice areas, client focus, and reputation in the legal community. I also considered their geographic coverage within the Fourth Department and their ability to handle complex appeals from start to finish.

Here's a quick look at the top five appellate law firms in Western New York, ranked from 1 to 5.

Detailed Reviews of Each Firm

#1 Tarantino Law Firm, LLP

A screenshot of the Tarantino Law Firm, LLP website.

Tarantino Law Firm, LLP, based in Buffalo, has a dedicated appellate practice that has helped shape New York law in several areas. Their team of experienced appellate attorneys handles a wide range of cases, including medical malpractice, personal injury, insurance coverage, and professional negligence. They emphasize that an appeal is a different proceeding entirely, requiring a unique set of skills. The firm has a strong reputation for both protecting favorable judgments and overturning adverse ones. If you need a firm with deep resources and a track record of appellate success, this is a top choice.

#2 Rupp Baase Pfalzgraf Cunningham LLC

A screenshot of the Rupp Baase Pfalzgraf Cunningham LLC website.

Rupp Baase Pfalzgraf Cunningham LLC, also in Buffalo, offers a comprehensive appeals practice as part of their broader litigation services. Their attorneys handle appeals in personal injury, business litigation, and white-collar defense, among other areas. The firm is known for its aggressive representation and deep experience in both trial and appellate courts. They provide a dedicated team that works closely with clients throughout the appeal process. For those seeking a firm with a strong litigation backbone, this is a solid option.

#3 Brenna Boyce PLLC

A screenshot of the Brenna Boyce PLLC website.

Brenna Boyce PLLC, located in Rochester, has a long history dating back to 1953, with Robert L. Brenna Jr. bringing decades of appellate experience. The firm concentrates on Supreme Court and appellate practice, and Brenna has been recognized by Premier Appellate Lawyers for his expertise. They handle a variety of civil appeals and have a strong track record in state and federal courts. If you want a firm with a legacy of appellate advocacy in Rochester, this is a strong contender.

#4 Experienced Appellate Law Attorney in Western New York

A screenshot of the DiPasquale Law PLLC website.

DiPasquale Law PLLC, led by Andrew J. DiPasquale, Esq., is a dedicated appellate law practice based in Rochester. The firm specializes in criminal, family, and civil appeals, focusing on correcting legal errors from lower court proceedings. DiPasquale's background as a prosecutor and his experience in the New York State legislature give him a unique perspective on appellate arguments. The firm serves clients across the entire Fourth Department, covering 22 counties. For personalized appellate representation with a focus on criminal and family law, this firm is a great fit.

#5 Schneider Buchel LLP

A screenshot of the Schneider Buchel LLP website.

Schneider Buchel LLP, with an office in Rochester, offers appellate law services as part of their broader practice, which includes community association law and commercial litigation. Their appellate attorneys focus on precise legal advocacy and clear communication with clients throughout the appeal process. They handle appeals from trial court decisions, including pre-trial and interim orders. If you need an appellate attorney who also understands the nuances of community association law, this firm is worth considering.

How to Choose the Right Appellate Law Firm for You

Start by looking at the firm's experience with your specific type of case, whether it's criminal, family, or civil. Consider the size of the firm and whether you prefer a large team with broad resources or a smaller, more personalized practice. Check their geographic coverage to ensure they handle appeals in your county within the Fourth Department. Finally, schedule a consultation to gauge their communication style and commitment to your case.

Streamlining Your Appeal Process

While the legal work itself requires human expertise, you can automate parts of your search for an appellate attorney. Use online directories and legal databases to filter firms by practice area and location. Set up alerts for new case law in the Fourth Department to stay informed. Automate your document organization with cloud-based tools to keep your trial records and briefs accessible.

Your Next Step in the Appeals Process

Choosing the right appellate law firm is a critical decision that can impact the outcome of your case. The five firms listed here represent the best options in Western New York, each with their own strengths. Whether you need the full-service approach of Tarantino Law Firm or the personalized touch of DiPasquale Law PLLC, you have solid choices. Reach out to a few of these firms to discuss your appeal and find the best fit for your needs.